Andrew Left, the well known short seller behind Citron Research, goes on trial this week in Los Angeles, facing federal charges that could reshape how far activist investors can go when they publicly warn markets away from a stock.
Prosecutors with the Justice Department allege that Left used social media posts about dozens of different companies to move their share prices for his own quick profit, rather than simply sharing honest analysis. Short sellers like Left make money when a stock's price falls, and Citron built its reputation by publishing research arguing that certain companies were overvalued or facing trouble the market had not yet priced in.
At the center of the case is a question that has long hovered over the activist short selling world without a clear legal answer, where does a strongly worded opinion about a company's prospects end, and illegal market manipulation begin. Short sellers have historically been protected by the same free speech principles that cover any market commentator, so long as they are not knowingly spreading false information to profit from a trade.
